Classroom Video: Accountability  Section 3: Student Share
Opposites Attract
Lesson 9 of 12
Objective: SWBAT solve story problems with related addition and subtraction facts. SWBAT explain that the addition and subtraction facts are related, though they may not be able to explain why yet.
Setting Up the Learning
Note to the Teacher:
The concepts taught in this lessonthe commutative property and the relationship between addition and subtractionare multilayered and complex. In this lesson, students are introduced to the idea that addition and subtraction are related for the first time. Expect this to be a process! At this point, I want students to be able to notice that the the two operations are related in some way, even if they aren't able to explain how they are opposite yet.
Review:
We have been investigating the relationship between addition problems that have the same two addends. We saw that it didn’t matter what order you put the numbers in, they equal the same sum. Today we are going to look at how addition and subtraction can be related. We are going to look at two problemsone is an addition problem, one is a subtraction problem. I want us to see if we can figure out how these two problems are the same and how they are different.
Connect:
Addition and subtraction are opposites. In addition we get more. In subtraction we take away. But they are related. When we figure out how they are related, it will help us solve problems in our head.
Objective: How are the addition and subtraction facts related?
Resources (1)
Resources (1)
Resources
Opening Discussion
I'll quickly read one of the cookie problems and share a student's answer from the Flip Flop plan. Go here to see this plan!
I have 5 cookies. I get 3 more cookies. How many cookies do I have now?
Today we are going to figure out a different story. In this story, you are going to get some cookies, but then you are going to eat those cookies right away!
Now you have 8 cookies. You eat the 3 new cookies! How many cookies do you have now?
Guiding Questions:

What is happening in this problem?

How is this problem similar to the problem we just read and solved?
Partner talk: Solve this problem with a partner. How many cookies do you have now?

How are the number sentences the same?

How are they different?

Why does the subtraction sentence start with 8? Let’s look at both of these stories with 2 different colors of cubes. I’ll act out the problem with a student.
Think Aloud: We had 5, we put 3 with it and then we had 8. When we took the 3 away, it was the opposite of getting more cookies, we took them right away! And now we only have 5 left.
Resources (1)
Resources (1)
Resources
Student Share
During this part of the lesson, I'll give each student or each pair of students 10 cubes to model the problem. I'll have one student to also model the action on the class number line. The Common Core standards ask students to be able to model problems in a variety of ways, this portion of the lesson exposes students to at least 2 ways to solve.
Focus Question: How are these story problems the same and different?
Present problem:
I have 5 cookies. My mom gives me 4 more cookies. How many cookies do I have now?
Students model with cubes and then watch as we model what they did on the number line.
I have 9 cookies. I eat my 4 of the cookies. How many cookies do I have now?
Students model with cubes and then watch as we model what they did on the number line.
Debrief questions:

On the number linewhere were the 6 new cookies? I'll focus on how they were the jumps that we made.

What happened when we took the cookies away on the number line? Why did we go back to where we started?

Write number sentences for both. How are these number sentences the same? How are they different?
Resources (1)
Resources (1)
Resources
Independent Practice
See video for how I differentiate student work, particularly with scaffolded questioning.
The attached document is the master copy of the independent practice. I left the numbers out so you can write numbers in to the problem that match your students' needs. They also provide space for students to write about their strategy, which is aligned to the CCSS emphasis on writing across the curriculum.
Resources (3)
Closing
We will close the lesson with all students back together on the carpet.
I’ll choose related facts that a student had and ask:
What is the answer to the addition sentence?
How can the addition sentence help you with this subtraction sentence?
Resources (1)
Resources (1)
Resources
Similar Lessons
Add or subtract using word problems
Environment: Urban
Combine and Compare
Environment: Suburban
Addition: Vocabulary Introduction
Environment: Urban
 UNIT 1: Creating a Culture of Math
 UNIT 2: Count to 100 Every Day!
 UNIT 3: 10: A First Grader's Best Friend
 UNIT 4: Charting and Analyzing Data
 UNIT 5: Inch by Inch, Paperclip by Paperclip
 UNIT 6: Properties of Addition and Subtraction
 UNIT 7: Shapes and Blocks
 UNIT 8: Understanding Equality
 UNIT 9: Adding and Subtracting: Base Ten
 UNIT 10: Solving 3 Addend Problems
 UNIT 11: Missing Parts: Unknowns in All Positions
 UNIT 12: Parts of a Whole
 UNIT 13: Tick Tock, Tick Tock
 UNIT 14: Time is Money: Hitting all the MD Standards
 UNIT 15: Base 10 Bonanza
 UNIT 16: What the WHAT?! Teaching Challenging Story Problems
 LESSON 1: Peas and Carrots...Carrots and Peas
 LESSON 2: Crayon Box Combinations
 LESSON 3: Wave a Magic Wand
 LESSON 4: Mathematical Symbols
 LESSON 5: Making the Minus Make Sense
 LESSON 6: Mixing It Up
 LESSON 7: There were 15 zombies...
 LESSON 8: Flip Flop
 LESSON 9: Opposites Attract
 LESSON 10: Thanksgiving Fact Family
 LESSON 11: A Grinchy Christmas
 LESSON 12: Toymaking with the Elves