Reflection: Flexibility Should Your School Get Rid of Sports? - Section 3: Wrap Up


Something unexpected came out of this lesson...I had not planned it, but my students learned a bit about the value of being open minded.  The value of listening to another's argument without prior judgment.

This occurred because as we were reading and discussing this piece, my athletic students closed their mind and missed important information. For example, they thought the writer was completely anti-sports instead of seeing that her claim was that we need to cut back NOT cut out.  They also did not consider that if the school in the story had to close students would be separated from friends.

My school is an independent in an area where three counties meet.  I used this as an example.  I had students go to separate areas of the room based on what county they live in.  Then, I explained that if our school closed as the one is the story almost did, they would be bused to he school in their own county. Hence, they would be serrated.  This changed their thinking.  

  Open Mindedness in Argument
  Flexibility: Open Mindedness in Argument
Loading resource...

Should Your School Get Rid of Sports?

Unit 9: Argument - Part 1
Lesson 2 of 15

Objective: SWBAT trace the argument in two pieces of text arguing opposite sides of the same issue.

Big Idea: Controversy here we come...

  Print Lesson
29 teachers like this lesson
no sports
Similar Lessons
Informational Writing: It's Tool Time! (Day 4 of 15)
3rd Grade ELA » Informational Writing Project
Big Idea: In order to be successful at any job, you need the right tools. Before we start collecting information, we need an organizational tool - the research notebook. Students learn how to use it correctly and avoid common research mistakes.
Environment: Rural
Jennifer Martinez
Learning the Genre of Persuasive Essay
7th Grade ELA » Using Mentor Texts, Generating Ideas, and Planning for Drafting of Persuasive Essays
Big Idea: What do you want?
Seattle, WA
Environment: Urban
Gina Wickstead
Day 4! So, How did I do? A peer to peer review!
7th Grade Math » Expressions and Equations 5 Day Application of Vocabulary Mini Unit
Big Idea: Students will engage in MP 3 in order to assess one another’s resource and make any changes necessary to make sure it is a vital and useful resource to use for the upcoming unit.
Columbus, OH
Environment: Urban
Malissa Thomas-St.Clair
Something went wrong. See details for more info
Nothing to upload