## Reflection: Discourse and Questioning The Pythagorean Identity - Section 1: The Ball is on the Tee!

It never fails, this is a fun portion of the lesson once the students get going with it!  "Proof by Example" (rather, lack there of) is a difficult thing for the students to understand until they begin to apply it to their own world.  I have an excellent light hearted relationship with many of my students, so here is an example of how I get things started with a specific example...

Claire, you think that Jimmy is really mean right?  Well does Jimmy being mean imply that EVERY boy is mean?  Usually there is a good deal of light-hearted humor that is going on right now.  After this has subsided, I ask the students if they can think of any other appropriate examples.

One student told me the following:  My Chevrolet truck broke down on the way to school yesterday.  That doesn't mean that ALL chevy trucks are junk!

I allow my students time to think of other "proof by examples" and we also try to pick out instances in society where we improperly utilize this.  I conclude the conversation by noting that not only is it wrong in this setting, but it is also wrong in mathematics.  It is a nice little transition into the remainder of the lesson.

When "Proof by Example" isn't really proof at all...
Discourse and Questioning: When "Proof by Example" isn't really proof at all...

# The Pythagorean Identity

Unit 7: Trig Tidbits
Lesson 14 of 16

## Big Idea: Making connections between the Pythagorean Theorem and The Pythagorean Identity.

Print Lesson
3 teachers like this lesson
Standards:
Subject(s):
Math, Trigonometry, Trigonometric functions, Algebra II, master teacher project
45 minutes

### Jarod Hammel

##### Similar Lessons

###### The Trigonometric Functions
Algebra II » Trigonometric Functions
Big Idea: The unit circle allows us to extend the trigonometric functions beyond the confines of a right triangle.
Favorites(8)
Resources(18)
Fort Collins, CO
Environment: Suburban

###### Riding a Ferris Wheel - Day 2 of 2
12th Grade Math » Trigonometric Functions
Big Idea: Make the transition from the Ferris wheel problem to the unit circle.
Favorites(5)
Resources(10)
Troy, MI
Environment: Suburban