Reflection: Intervention and Extension Persepolis Star Seminar: Small Group Debrief - Section 4: Star Seminar Debrief Discussion: Mixed Groups


There is a part of me that wishes I had done this instead of doing the star seminar. I could have cut part of the time out and I think the students would have been fine. I was really hoping for the opportunity to see how all of them would do in a seminar format with the whole class--something I like to do at the beginning of each semester--but this was where the best dialogue actually happened.

In these jigsaw groups, students had to haggle with each other about the most significant ideas in Persepolis and provide justification for their thinking. I was able to see who the natural conversation leaders are and heard them taking on the responsibility for making sure each of their classmates was contributing to the conversation. In this model, the groups were small enough that even the most timid students offered at least one thought to the conversation.

The one down side is that I couldn't listen to all the groups with equal focus. I wandered the room a few times, but really focused my attention on half of the groups while my teaching partner listened in on the other half of the groups. He marked when they spoke and if they said something significant, but I don't feel like I can really score them in a summative way on the speaking standards as I didn't hear each of them individually. This is going to be a constant dilemma for me as it is hard to assess speaking and listening with 58 students.

  Best Part of the Seminar
  Intervention and Extension: Best Part of the Seminar
Loading resource...

Persepolis Star Seminar: Small Group Debrief

Unit 2: Narrative Reading and Writing: Persepolis and Memoir
Lesson 7 of 11

Objective: SWBAT develop their own understanding of the text by participating in small group seminar discussions.

Big Idea: Being able to state and support a claim about text is a difficult thing--providing scaffolded opportunities to be successful with this is essential in the high school ELA classroom.

  Print Lesson
star seminar debrief
Similar Lessons
Stereotypical and Iconic Images Depicted in Drama: Baseball and the N-Word in Fences, Act 1 Scene 1
9th Grade ELA » Fences: Character and Theme Analysis in Drama
Big Idea: How do the images of America's favorite past time and racial stereotypes impact the disempowered?

Environment: Urban
Donna Fletcher
Analyzing Character’s Influence on Theme in Night, Chapters 1-6
10th Grade ELA » What It Means to be Human
Big Idea: Is a character influenced by theme, or is theme influenced by character?
Independence, MO
Environment: Suburban
Lindsay Thompson
Who is Esperanza and what shapes her identity in "The House on Mango Street"?
9th Grade ELA » The Search for Identity: "The House on Mango Street"
Big Idea: Point me to it! Students work together to figure out the point of the book and answer its essential question.
Bel Air, MD
Environment: Suburban
Paula Stanton, PhD
Something went wrong. See details for more info
Nothing to upload