##
* *Reflection: Grappling with Complexity
Working with Larger Numbers - Section 2: Teaching the Lesson

The warm up and teaching of the lesson went so well today. I was excited that students were able to deal with hundreds, tens and ones to both add and subtract. They panicked a little when I switched from addition to subtraction, but when I told them to use the same strategies we had been using with addition, such as working with hundreds, tens and ones, writing the problem in columns or covering the hundreds, solving the problem as if it were a 2 digit number and then putting the hundreds back on the number, they quickly solved 3 digit subtraction problems that did not require regrouping. I was feeling like "Wow, they get it."

Then I handed them a few of the word problems they had created. I made sure none required regrouping. The problems were now in words not numbers. Half of the class (or at least it seemed like half) started with "I can't do this." "I don't know how."

I was disappointed, to say the least. What do you mean you can't?, I was thinking to myself. "Of course you can, you just did it." I was patient with the first child or two, but by the third I was getting frustrated. I had to stop and think, why aren't they getting it? Why is it suddenly too hard?

Of course, the format had changed! So I stopped and called the group back together. We talked about how a picture might help, or writing the numbers in a number sentence would make it just like what we had been doing together.

I reminded them that there is no such thing as "I can't." They might need help, and if I see them starting, maybe with a picture, or with writing out the numbers, I would help, but that if they just sit and stare, I really can't help because I don't know what they have already tried.

After that, I was able to help those students who were trying a starting point, and many were able to help themselves.

Don't give up when kids say they can't. Remind them that they can. Help them to get started, review with them what they know and help them to build from there. They can (and so can you!).

*Dealing with the I Can'ts*

*Grappling with Complexity: Dealing with the I Can'ts*

# Working with Larger Numbers

Lesson 4 of 9

## Objective: SWBAT use addition and subtraction strategies to work with larger numbers generated by their measurement data

## Big Idea: Students generated data about rolling objects in part 1 of this lesson. Now they need to work on strategies for adding and subtracting the numbers they found.

*45 minutes*

#### Warm Up

*15 min*

Today I want to review using place value to add and subtract larger numbers. I put the numbers 120 + 245 on the board vertically. I ask students how they might add such large numbers?

I have several volunteers come up and show us their strategies for adding the larger numbers. I reinforce the adding of hundreds, tens and ones if a child shows that strategy, if that does not come up, I will ask "could I add the hundreds digits?" What would that give me?" "What about the tens?" "What about the ones?"

I repeat this process with the numbers 356 + 313.

I know that the numbers they generated in their data will give them some situations over 10 in the ones column, or over 100 in the tens column and I will address this in the Teaching the Lesson section, but for the warm up, I don't choose any digit combinations that add to over 9.

Now I present a subtraction problem the same way. I put 456 - 124 on the board and ask can we use what we know of hundreds, tens and ones to subtract this problem? I ask for a volunteer to show us this on the board. We talk about subtracting the ones ---- 6 - 4, then the tens ----- 50 - 20, and then the hundreds ----- 400 - 100. We also talk about starting with the ones (which will make it easier when they do need to regroup later on).

I ask them to solve the problem 596 - 375 in their math books. What do they find? I have several volunteers come and show us their solutions.

#### Resources

*expand content*

#### Teaching the Lesson

*20 min*

I want to help students to be able to add and subtract with the data they have gathered. I know this may call for regrouping, which they are not quite ready for and so I need to provide some strategies for dealing with these numbers.

I tell students that they have generated some very large numbers by rolling clay balls and logs (spheres and cylinders) down a ramp. Now, I want them to be able to solve some problems about the distances. Today, we are going to talk about some strategies that we might use to deal with larger numbers.

I show students the numbers 66 and 39. I create a scenario. A person rolled a white log 66 cm and a white ball 39 cm. I want to know the difference in the distance the items traveled, or how much further the log rolled. I ask, "What can I do to find the difference?" We discuss student ideas, such as counting up from 39 to 66, or down from 66 to 39. What tools might I use? (Number line, number grid, tally marks, pictures, blocks.) I ask students to pick a tool. and use their best strategic thinking to find the difference. I am asking students to make sense of a problem here and then use a strategy to persevere in solving the problem (MP1). I am also encouraging students to use concrete models here to solve the problem (2NBT.7)

Next, another story. I have a yellow ball that rolled 146cm, and a yellow log that rolled 58 cm. Can I still count up or down? Is there a way to make that easier? If no one has an idea I say, "What if I count up 2 from 58 to get to 60? Next, can I count by tens to 140?" We try...70, 80, 90, 100, 110, 120, 130, 140. How much was the difference, to get from 60 to 140? 80. Did we have any other changes? We already had 2 so altogether? 82 Are we done with the ones? We have 6 ones left, so what is 82 + 6? 88. So our difference is 88 cm.

We practice several other combinations of counting up and down.

Next we try a problem where we have 186 - 62. We discuss how we can pretend that the 100 is not there, count from 62 to 86, and then add the 100 back on.

When I feel that students are able to apply a variety of strategies to manipulate larger numbers, I present some of the problems that students created from their data the previous day. I ask students to work independently to solve the problems.

#### Resources

*expand content*

#### Closing

*10 min*

I want students to review their own work. Having me correct papers when students are not in the room provides little learning experience for the children. They may or may not look at my corrections, and for most of them, they will just take the papers home.

Today I take the time to review the problems with the group. I encourage students to share their solutions. We go over each problem and share solutions. Students see how others solved the problems. They gain confidence in themselves when they see that they figured the problem out. Part of being successful in math is in believing you can be successful in math. I want my 2nd graders to not only have a foundation of skills and knowledge, I also want them to believe in themselves as capable problem solvers.

*expand content*

##### Similar Lessons

###### 10, 20, 100 Day 2

*Favorites(1)*

*Resources(15)*

Environment: Suburban

###### I've Got More Than You

*Favorites(42)*

*Resources(17)*

Environment: Rural

###### Adding Three-Digit Numbers Without Regrouping

*Favorites(5)*

*Resources(15)*

Environment: Urban

- UNIT 1: What and Where is Math?
- UNIT 2: Adding and Subtracting the Basics
- UNIT 3: Sensible Numbers
- UNIT 4: Sensible Numbers
- UNIT 5: Everything In Its Place
- UNIT 6: Everything in Its Place
- UNIT 7: Place Value
- UNIT 8: Numbers Have Patterns
- UNIT 9: Fractions
- UNIT 10: Money
- UNIT 11: The Numbers Are Getting Bigger
- UNIT 12: More Complex Numbers and Operations
- UNIT 13: Area, Perimeter and More Measurement
- UNIT 14: Length
- UNIT 15: Geometry
- UNIT 16: Getting Ready to Multiply
- UNIT 17: Getting Better at Addition and Subtraction
- UNIT 18: Strategies That Work

- LESSON 1: Math Treasure Hunt
- LESSON 2: Measurement and Symmetry
- LESSON 3: Adding and Subtracting with Lengths
- LESSON 4: Working with Larger Numbers
- LESSON 5: Larger Distances
- LESSON 6: How Big Is A Foot?
- LESSON 7: Bigger Than A Foot
- LESSON 8: Centimeters and Inches
- LESSON 9: Measuring in Centimeters