Reflection: Checks for Understanding Where is the Question - Section 2: Teaching the Lesson


We concentrated today on finding the words in word problems that help us to know whether to add or subtract. The students did a great job finding the words, and were able to determine if they needed to add or subtract.

But, then they were not careful with the computation. One group gave 55 as the answer for 85 - 35. When questioned, they said they took 3 away from 8 to get 5. (I asked if this was tens or ones and they said tens.) Here students were not attending to the precision of solving the problem (MP6)

Then they told me they subtracted 5 from 5 and got 0, but they wrote 55. When I pointed this out they had trouble seeing why the 55 was different from what they told me.

I saw similar mistakes with other partnerships. I think I need to teach students about checking their work to see if it makes sense. 

I realized that determining the operation was taking a lot of the “brain” focus in this activity.  Also numerical sense making is  not yet in place.  Although one of my goals is for students to make sense of the problem (MP1), and persevere in solving it, I realized that students had trouble maintaining the focus and stamina to do both. When the focus is only on manipulating numbers, they are in the “groove”, but now like are being asked to juggle two things - determining operation and manipulate numbers. It will take additional practice for them to be able to maintain the focus throughout a 2 part problem such as these.


  FInding the Words, Forgetting the Math
  Checks for Understanding: FInding the Words, Forgetting the Math
Loading resource...

Where is the Question

Unit 17: Getting Better at Addition and Subtraction
Lesson 1 of 12

Objective: SWBAT identify the problem and operation within a word problem.

Big Idea: Students can perform addition and subtraction within 100 using a variety of math tools, however, determining which operation to use is a higher level thinking skill that is being introduced in this lesson.

  Print Lesson
Math, Number Sense and Operations, addition, reasoning, word problems, Operations
  65 minutes
100 0760
Similar Lessons
Cover Up
1st Grade Math » Counting by Groups
Big Idea: Yesterday we added it up and today we cover it up. Students will work in pairs as they cover random numbers on a number grid and ask their partner to figure out which numbers are Covered Up!
Waitsfield, VT
Environment: Suburban
Thomas Young
Domino Addition: Understanding the Part/Part/Whole Relationship
2nd Grade Math » Addition and Subtraction Basic Training
Big Idea: The big idea of this lesson is the understanding that addition can be represented as parts of a whole and that we can use addition sentences to represent those parts.
Pepperell, MA
Environment: Rural
Kristen O'Connor
It's As Basic As That
3rd Grade Math » Understanding Multiplication
Big Idea: Students need to master the basic operations. The common core suggests that all four operations are mastered by the end of third grade. This lesson will help determine where to start and what to do next.
Troy, MI
Environment: Suburban
Michelle Marcus
Something went wrong. See details for more info
Nothing to upload