##
* *Reflection: Student Led Inquiry
Cooking with Mathmaster Chef (Day 4 of 4) - Section 2: Warm Up

It's really easy here to over clarify and take away some of the confusion. But this lesson was designed specifically to be confusing in order to highlight and surface some common errors. The confusion can result in productive figuring. **In problems like these (+2 - 3, -3 + 2, -1 - 2) my students often ask if the - means "minus" or "negative". **This lesson forces them to think about context and decide what makes sense.

In the past I used to just read the problem to them in two ways: "positive two negative three", "positive two minus three" and ask them which made sense. **I think this robbed them of a little bit of the sense making and was especially unhelpful for my EL students.** I want my students to realize that only one interpretation results in a complete mathematical expression and a misinterpretation leaves the expression without an operator.

**To maintain the cognitive demand on my students instead of me taking it over I try to ask questions that will prompt them to think about the context to help make sense of the math.**

- What do you think it
*might*mean? - What makes you say that?
- Why does that make sense?
- Does that make sense? why/why not? (to group)
- If that is true, what
*might*(this negative sign/this number) represent? - If this (negative sign) represents subtraction could it represent cold cubes at the same time?
- If this (negative sign) represents 'take away' then what type of cubes does the number represent?
- If this (positive sign) represents addition then what type of cubes does the number represent?

**After this series of questions there were two distinct conclusions**. **In either case I asked the class to decide if the chef would get angry at us for asking him to clarify his directions.**

Some of my students decided that the middle symbol was an operator and interpreted the expressions in a couple of ways:

- +2 - 3 could be "add 2 hot cubes & remove 3 hot cubes"
- -3 + 2 could be "add 3 cold cubes (or remove 3 hot cubes) & add 2 hot cubes
- -1 - 2 could be "add 1 cold cube (or remove 1 hot cube) & remove 2 hot cubes

In this case I wanted students to notice that either interpretation would result in the same temperature change, so we should NOT ask for clarification. When several students thought we should ask I told them the chef would get mad and made them figure out why.

Another conclusion (which I did not expect) was that Mathmaster Chef was a chef and not a mathematician, so he wouldn't necessarily record directions as a correct mathematical expressionand he might have left out the addition and subtraction signs. **At first I thought this was not worth pursuing, but I asked the questions anyway (about whether we should ask for clarification) and was surprised by a near consensus.** Many of the group discussions brought up the fact that we needed to ask for clarification in this situation, because a misinterpretation would result in the opposite of the desired effect.* For example by +2 - 3 Mathmaster Chef might have been listing the cubes he wanted us to remove or the cubes he wanted us to add and removing 2 hot cubes and 3 cold cubes would have the opposite effect of adding 2 hot cubes and 3 cold cubes*. In retrospect I decided to always ask rather than assume.

*Questions to prompt thinking*

*Student Led Inquiry: Questions to prompt thinking*

# Cooking with Mathmaster Chef (Day 4 of 4)

Lesson 4 of 24

## Objective: SWBAT interpret a numeric integer addition and subtraction expression using the context of hot and cold cubes

*54 minutes*

This lesson is meant to help students transition from the concrete model to a mathematical model by presenting them with the mathematical model and asking them to interpret it based on the context. Adding and subtracting integers can be very confusing for students because it seems to contradict their prior knowledge and experience with addition and subtraction. Suddenly we are subtracting when the problem says to add or adding when the problem says to subtract. Suddenly numbers aren't always getting bigger when we add or smaller when we subtract. Many models we use with middle school students are not as accessible as the hot and cold cubes, because they require experiences that students may not have had, like borrowing and lending. This context helps them make sense of the math.

The warmup helps students to both transition from the concrete to the abstract by using the context to make sense of the mathematical model and also to reinforce the equivalence of subtracting and adding the opposite for students who may be ready. I also want to encourage choice making, so they realize they have some autonomy and flexibility in problem solving.

*expand content*

#### Warm Up

*15 min*

Slide 24 of the powerpoint Hot and Cold cubes is the warm up for students today. It asks what the Mathmaster Chef could want his assistant to do with hot and cold cubes if the only notes he left were:

+2 - 3 - 3 + 2 - 1 - 2

As I circulate I encourage students to write out what the directions our chef left could be telling us to do with cubes.

**Could he be asking us to add or take out cubes?****Which kind of cubes?****Could the directions be interpreted another way?**

I look to see if students come up with different ways of interpreting the directions, either within the same math family group or between the groups. I am hoping they will so that I can ask them if we need to ask Mathmaster Chef for clarification on his directions. I would remind them that Mathmaster Chef is very tempermental and yells at his assistants when they can't figure things out on their own, but he also yells if they get the temperature wrong, so we have to be careful.

Slides 25 - 27 follow with more expressions. Ask students if we need to ask for clarification of the directions since there are sometimes more than one interpretation? **Whatever they answer, ask them to explain why or why not.** Hopefully, one of them will say that we get the same temperature change either way, so it doesn't matter which one we do. If not, I encourage them to find the temperature change either way. When they see that it results in the same temperature change I ask what they think Mathmaster Chef's reaction would be if we asked for clarification? I will point out that assistants like us can make some decisions on their own. As long as they are interpreting the numeric expression in at least one way using hot and cold cubes, they will be fine.

*expand content*

#### Powerpoint exploration

*39 min*

Slide 28 of the powerpoint Hot and Cold cubes asks what Mathmaster Chef wants his assistant to do if his directions are 2 - (-2). Students should only interpret this in one way "add two hot cubes and take out 2 cold cubes" They will likely try to interpret it in another way since the three before had multiple methods. As they work on this I circulate to highlight argumentation at the math family groups. Even though there is only one interpretation students may find an equivalent method of adding 2 hot cubes and 2 more hot cubes instead. If they don't I will ask if there is another way the assistant could get the same result.

Follow the same type of questioning for slides 29 and 30. Both of these do have multiple interpretations. I would ask how they know that each interpretation is equivalent and which they might choose to do and why.

The last slide is very open ended and gives rise to many different methods for reaching a temperature decrease of 8. I want them to work in groups so that they can see different methods and ideas. The slide tells them the chef added some cubes, removed some cubes, then added some more cubes, and asks what he might have done. The question is purposely vague. They might come up with a way for the chef to add, subtract, then add cubes to reach -8 or they might choose their own equiv alent method as an option for the chef. After students share multiple methods I ask what they would do to reinforce autonomy and choice. Autonomy and choice are so important because students taught traditionally wait for all the directions to be given by the teacher, but it's only when they are forced to make choices that they truly become flexible with the math and utilize the relationships they have uncovered.

#### Resources

*expand content*

*Your lesson plan is fantastic because it prompts the students to think and work together. Thanks for sharing! | one month ago | Reply*

##### Similar Lessons

###### Integers: Number Lines and Absolute Values

*Favorites(97)*

*Resources(18)*

Environment: Urban

###### Pre Test

*Favorites(25)*

*Resources(9)*

Environment: Urban

Environment: Urban

- UNIT 1: Order of operations & Number properties
- UNIT 2: Writing expressions
- UNIT 3: Equivalent Expressions
- UNIT 4: Operations with Integers
- UNIT 5: Writing and comparing ratios
- UNIT 6: Proportionality on a graph
- UNIT 7: Percent proportions
- UNIT 8: Exploring Rational Numbers
- UNIT 9: Exploring Surface Area
- UNIT 10: Exploring Area & Perimeter

- LESSON 1: Cooking with The Mathmaster Chef (Day 1 of 4)
- LESSON 2: Cooking with Mathmaster Chef (Day 2 of 4)
- LESSON 3: Cooking with Mathmaster Chef (Day 3 of 4)
- LESSON 4: Cooking with Mathmaster Chef (Day 4 of 4)
- LESSON 5: Which Way Do We Go?
- LESSON 6: Intervention Day
- LESSON 7: The Three Little Bears
- LESSON 8: Secret Numbers
- LESSON 9: Patterns in Addition
- LESSON 10: How Do You Know?
- LESSON 11: Secret Number Sub Plan
- LESSON 12: Patterns in Subtraction Sub Plan
- LESSON 13: Patterns in Subtraction (Day 2 of 2)
- LESSON 14: Patterns in Subtraction
- LESSON 15: Equivalent Expressions
- LESSON 16: Matching Equivalent Expressions
- LESSON 17: Magic Witch Hats
- LESSON 18: Is it Postive or Negative?
- LESSON 19: Integer Addition & Subtraction Assessment
- LESSON 20: Multiplying with Mathmaster Chef (Day 1 of 2)
- LESSON 21: Multiplying with Mathmaster Chef (Day 2 of 2)
- LESSON 22: Integer Product Game
- LESSON 23: Patterns in Mutliplication and Division
- LESSON 24: Integer multiplication & division assessment