Reflection: Discourse and Questioning History of Earth: Part 1: Discovery - Section 5: Discussion


I just started using Socratic Seminars this year and I LOVE them.  The big idea in a Socratic Seminar is that students are using a high level resource in a group discussion where students build off of each others' answers.  The first time I experimented we had some problems with kids shouting out vs kids raising their hands.  Personally, I try to be as little involved as possible, which means I like the students to decide who should talk just like they do in "real" conversations.  Now, I let the conversations go unless they get too excited, which is when I gently step in to call on certain students and slow the pace.  

The interesting results I found in using a Socratic Seminar is that it gives different kids a chance to shine. It's not just about the fastest readers or best's about the kids that love to verbally process and interact.  As you can see  from the picture...this means that not every student participates every time.  I'm OK with this because I also have the notes to tell me which students got the information and there is a project at the end of the movie to help give me a different picture of student learning.  

  Socratic Seminars
  Discourse and Questioning: Socratic Seminars
Loading resource...

History of Earth: Part 1: Discovery

Unit 12: History of Earth: Part 1
Lesson 1 of 7

Objective: Students will be able to gather information about Earth's formation from a resource.

Big Idea: The Earth started as a ball of dust?!!

  Print Lesson
51 teachers like this lesson
formation of
Similar Lessons
Introduction to Change Over Time
8th Grade Science » Understanding Our Changing Climate: Systems Thinking & Global Heating
Big Idea: Use this fun and simple game to introduce your students to concepts of Systems Thinking.
Brookline, MA
Environment: Urban
Ryan Keser
Convection Currents
7th Grade Science » Earth Science
Big Idea: What causes tectonic plate movement? Could the answer be the convection currents in the mantle?
Hope, IN
Environment: Rural
Deborah Gaff
You Are a Time Traveler at the Museum
4th Grade Science » Fossils
Big Idea: Using iPads or a camera and note taking skills, students learn to use a prehistoric exhibit to develop a timeline and show understanding of how the Earth tells history through rock layers.
Genoa City, WI
Environment: Rural
Mary Ellen Kanthack
Something went wrong. See details for more info
Nothing to upload