Reflection: Staircase of Complexity Spending & Saving, and Function Notation - Section 3: Spending & Saving, Part 1b


If you've taken a look at Part 1b, you might have noticed a few problems whose formal solutions would require the use of logarithms.  But is it necessary for a student to have heard of logarithms before they can solve these problems? 

A few of my students are involved in a program that pairs them with college students who volunteer as tutors.  One of my students came to class this morning to say that her tutor said she "shouldn't be learning this in 9th grade."  I find it disappointing that our educational system would lead a high school graduate to say that, because it indicates a belief that mathematics is some sort of sequentially-prescribed series of topics.    

Students are often exposed to mathematical ideas before they're ready for the formal procedures of more advanced algebra.  Or at least they should be!  That's the idea behind this Atlantic article from 2014.  The sub-heading for that article says, "Why playing with algebraic and calculus concepts—rather than doing arithmetic drills—may be a better way to introduce children to math."  Extending from that - playing with the numbers, using guess and check, or in this case, giving students a classic applications of logs before they're "in Algebra 2," builds in arithmetic drills without saying that's what we're doing.  If a student is searching for the value of x that makes 1.10^x > 20 true, they're getting a feel for the numbers, and getting more comfortable using exponents / understanding what happens to a non-integer when we raise it various powers.
With all of that said, I do introduce logarithms to any student with the awareness to ask about the algebraic step necessary to solve for a variable exponent.  There are always at least a few such students in any 9th grade algebra class.  When asked that question, I quickly review that we know that multiplication and division are inverse operations, and that the same goes for addition and subtraction.  Then, kids are excited to learn that there's a tool called a logarithm that's the inverse of an exponent.  They've seen the "log" button on their calculators, and they're happy to know a little about it.  I'll even have them run a few calculations to see how it works, but only after they find a satisfactory solution by some informal method.  Only after all that will I say, "you'll learn a lot more about logarithms later in high school."

  Teaching Logarithms in Algebra 1?
  Staircase of Complexity: Teaching Logarithms in Algebra 1?
Loading resource...

Spending & Saving, and Function Notation

Unit 8: Linear and Exponential Functions
Lesson 11 of 19

Objective: SWBAT interpret the parameters of linear and exponential functions. SWBAT use function notation, evaluate functions for inputs on their domains, and interpret statements that use function notation in the context of several financial situations.

Big Idea: Practice with a tool like function notation is important; interpreting what that representation means in context, even more so.

  Print Lesson
1 teacher likes this lesson
Math, Algebra, Function Operations and Inverses, Linear and Nonlinear Equations, function notation, Algebra 1, financial applications, linear function, exponential function
  43 minutes
part 1b student work front
Similar Lessons
Graphing Radical Functions Day 2
Algebra II » Radical Functions - It's a sideways Parabola!
Big Idea: Looking back over a number of examples, students make use of the structure of equations to anticipate the graph.
Fort Collins, CO
Environment: Suburban
Jacob Nazeck
The Function Game
12th Grade Math » Functioning with Functions
Big Idea: Functions are investigated using a game that is accessible and engaging.
Troy, MI
Environment: Suburban
Tim  Marley
What is a Function?
Algebra I » Linear & Absolute Value Functions
Big Idea: Students will identify whether a relation is a function by examining its inputs and outputs or with the vertical line test.
Washington, DC
Environment: Urban
Noelani Davis
Something went wrong. See details for more info
Nothing to upload