##
* *Reflection: Rigor
Specific Heat of a Metal Lab - Section 4: Evaluate

This was the first time that I had my students perform this lab so there are several things that I will change for next time.

- This was a fairly complicated lab in terms of written procedures so I will try to have this not be the first lab of the year where students write their own procedures. Next year I will definitely incorporate procedure writing into first semester, most likely in the introductory unit with something easier like density.

- I will engage students at the beginning of the lab by showing them the metals and the list of possible metals and ask if they can think of a way to determine what the metals are. I will expect them to come up with using density (because we did that first semester) but then will explain how we will be using specific heat capacity that we have been learning about in this unit.

- I will make sure to continue to give students instructions regarding the different types of water with one being to heat up the metal and the other for the calorimeter (there is further explanation of this in the elaborate section)

- I will make sure to give extra support to students as they are coming up with their procedures and performing their labs so that they really understand the point of the lab.

- In terms of the written instructions there are several changes I have made for next year and have updated the lab to this revised version.
- I added in the heat capacity of water in the background.
- I changed the materials list to reflect more of what students used in the lab.

*Rigor: Lab Revisions- Improvement for Next Time*

# Specific Heat of a Metal Lab

Lesson 9 of 9

## Objective: Student will be able to identify an unknown metal through performing an experiment to gather necessary specific heat data.

In this lesson students design a lab to determine the identity of an unknown metal through using specific heat calculations. This lesson builds on the previous lessons in the unit where students have already learned about specific heat capacity and have performed several calorimetry experiments including finding the heat of fusion of ice, the calories in a Cheeto, the calories of food (virtually), and the heat capacity of various substances (virtually).

- This lesson aligns with the Next Generation Performance Expectation of
**HS-PS 3-1***Create a computation model to calculate the change in the energy of one component in a system when the change in energy of the other component(s) and energy flows in and out of the system are known.*It does so because students use the specific heat equation to calculate the specific heat of an unknown metal.

- This lesson aligns with the
*Next Generation Crosscutting Concept 5: Energy and matter*. It does so because students are thinking about specific heat and how energy is transferred between systems.

- This lesson aligns with the
*NGSS Science and Engineering Practice 3: Planning and Carrying Out Investigations:*It does so because students come up with their own procedures for planning the lab and then carrying out the lab to gather the necessary data.

For this lesson various resources are needed for each lab group including:

- 250 mL beakers
- A way to heat the metal (either Bunsen Burner with wire gauze, ring stand and iron ring OR hot plate)
- Styrofoam cups
- metal shots (I give a different metal to each group from the metal shot kit from Flinn including copper, brass, aluminum, or steel)
- thermometers (glass and/or temperature probes)

*expand content*

#### Explain

*10 min*

I begin the lesson by having students take several minutes to read over the specific heat of a metal lab paper to themselves.

After several minutes I get students' attention and review the lab with them.

- I ask students what the goal of the lab is and call on a student to share out.
- I then show students examples of the metals and tell them that this is similar to what they did in Unit 1 where they identified an unknown metal using density (
*see my lesson Density Part II and Review)*, but this time they will be using specific heat. - I explain to students that they will be using calorimetry similar to the labs that they previously did in the unit to come up with their own procedures to perform this lab.
- I then point out the equations that students will be using to find specific heat capacity.
- I tell students that they will be coming up with their own procedures and to make sure that they are written so that somebody else could read through them and perform the lab.
- I point out that the five measurements indicated on the paper should be able to be found when following their written procedures.
- I then go over all of the lab equipment available to students which I have laid out on the front bench. While doing this I tell students that there are multiple ways to heat up water, so they will choose their materials based on their desired method.
- Many students get confused with the different waters used in the lesson (one for heating the metal, one for use in the calorimeter). I go over this in detail by demonstrating this to students as can be seen in this video. I tell students to make sure to use enough water to cover the metal in both the the beaker and the calorimeter (should be at least 50mL).

*expand content*

#### Elaborate

*70 min*

As students perform the lab I walk around to make sure that students are on task, help with questions, and review several parts of the lab that confuse students.

- I have each group choose an unknown metal from a Ziploc bag of metals which includes metal shot samples.

- In order to help the groups with confusion over the two types of water (one for heating the metal, one for the calorimeter) I spoke to each group on their own:
- I gave each group a 250 mL beaker and told them to use this to heat up the water with the metal and that whatever temperature the water is will be used as the initial temperature of the metal.

- I also gave each group a Styrofoam cup and a beaker and told them that they will be putting cold water from the sink into the Styrofoam cup. I told them that this water must be measured and the temperature of this water will be the initial temperature of the water.

- As students finish their procedures I make sure to check them before they go ahead with the lab. As I check the procedures I make sure that they allow for the collection of the five necessary measurements indicated on the lab paper. If students do not have the procedures written well I point out the steps where they are missing information or which measurements they are missing and tell them that I will come and check again in a few minutes.
- This movie shows how I check students lab procedures.
- As students complete their labs I tell them to look at the Metal specific heats list to determine which type of metal they had.

*expand content*

After students have competed their labs I grade them using the Specific Heat of a Metal Lab Rubric.

Here are some examples of graded labs:

- In this first example (Student Example #1) the student earned all of his points. You will notice that in his procedures there are changes made from when I checked the work of his group and pointed out that they were not giving enough detail. I like how this student simply crossed off parts and added in changes because I try to stress to students that making mistakes are okay and that science is messy. This student's data was not in a table but was still easy to read so I have full credit. Finally he had a good analysis and conclusion regarding the sample being tin.
- In this second example (Student Example #2) the student missed points on her procedure, analysis and conclusion. You will see that in her procedure she is missing some specifics in terms of how to measure the water, set up the Bunsen burner, and how to heat the metal. This student did have a good data table, but she missed the analysis and conclusion. She did not show her work as to how she determined the sample is tin (I assume she was copying from one of her partners) and did not show any of her work for the analysis.
- In this third example (Student Example #3 ) the student did a great job with her procedures and almost earned all of her points, but she was missing some of her work and units in the analysis section.

From grading the labs I found that the hardest struggle for students was being complete with writing their procedures and correctly plugging in their values for the analysis section.

*expand content*

*Great lesson! I love that it follows the 5E model. My kids were able to "see" specific heat as something that is usable rather than just word problems on a sheet of paper. Thanks for the great resource! | 10 months ago | Reply*

##### Similar Lessons

###### LAB: Is This Reaction Endothermic or Exothermic?

*Favorites(14)*

*Resources(15)*

Environment: Urban

Environment: Suburban

###### Introduction to Physics via Thermodynamics

*Favorites(5)*

*Resources(18)*

Environment: Rural

- UNIT 1: Unit 1: Working as a chemist
- UNIT 2: Unit 2: Matter, Atoms, and the Periodic Table
- UNIT 3: Unit 3: Bonding & Periodic Table Trends
- UNIT 4: Unit 5: Stoichiometry, Chemical Reactions, and First Semester Review
- UNIT 5: Unit 6: Energy
- UNIT 6: Unit 7: Earth's Atmosphere
- UNIT 7: Unit 8: Water Quality
- UNIT 8: Unit 9: Reaction Rates and Equilibrium
- UNIT 9: Unit 10: Nuclear Chemistry and Final Exam Review

- LESSON 1: Introduction to Energy: Types, Conservation, and Conversion of Energy
- LESSON 2: Temperature, Heat, Exothermic, and Endothermic Reactions
- LESSON 3: Energy Diagrams
- LESSON 4: The Energy of Phase Changes
- LESSON 5: Photosynthesis and Cellular Respiration
- LESSON 6: Specific Heat
- LESSON 7: Specific Heat Virtual Labs
- LESSON 8: Designing a Melting Device Lab
- LESSON 9: Specific Heat of a Metal Lab