## Reflection: ELL Students Amazing Animals - Graphing and Asking Questions - Section 4: Writing and Answering Questions About the Data (Comparisons)

The task of writing questions lends itself well to on-the-spot differentiation.  As this is a beginning of the year lesson, I'm still getting to know my students areas of strength and needed support.

I teach gifted students who also speak English as a 2nd language (about 2/3 of the class) and there is a wide variation of skills.  All students need work writing questions.  I meet them where they are.

If they are really struggling, I back up to the level of extremely simple questions. "How many fish did we name?"  I aim for on-level "How many more bony fish did we name than cartilaginous fish?" For kids ready for extension, I encourage two-step questions, such as the one I modeled and also ask them to consider the value of their question.

Sure, they can compare the number of spiders named to the number of snakes named, but what will be learned from that comparison?  I am always encouraging them to look for meaning, and if they see meaning in their questions, great, but if they are just making comparisons for no particular reason I ask them to consider how to make a more meaningful comparison or add-together question.

Writing Questions
ELL Students: Writing Questions

# Amazing Animals - Graphing and Asking Questions

Unit 1: 1st Week: Getting to Know Each Other Through Graphs
Lesson 5 of 6

## Big Idea: Students love animals and discussing the basic of animal classification and sharing what they know provides another activity that builds classroom community and a home-school connection.

Print Lesson
11 teachers like this lesson
Standards:
Subject(s):
Math, Classroom Culture and Climate, collecting data, Graphing
62 minutes

### Jennifer Valentine

##### Similar Lessons

###### Observable Properties Investigation
3rd Grade Science » Changes to Physical Properties
Big Idea: Students will identify how cooling affects the observable properties of different liquids.
Favorites(2)
Resources(12)
Silver Spring, MD
Environment: Suburban

###### Making a Line Graph
4th Grade Math » Measurement and Data
Big Idea: Students can use data from a table to determine the appropriate intervals to include on the "y" axis, then graph the data in a line graph.
Favorites(1)
Resources(13)
Memphis, TN
Environment: Urban

###### Wing Span
3rd Grade Math » Going Batty Over Measurement and Geometry
Big Idea: Many students create bar graphs and can explain questions like "more than" and "less than", but are not accustomed to actually gathering the data and building the graph from the ground up. This engaging lesson requires students to do all of the above.
Favorites(3)
Resources(11)
Troy, MI
Environment: Suburban