##
* *Reflection:
Commutative Property: First Grade Style - Section 3: Independent Practice

My goal in every lesson is to catch student mistakes right when they occur because I believe that the faster I provide feedback, the better it will help them in the future when they interact with the same concept. I know I am kind of setting the bar a little high by thinking this because it is impossible to catch every student mistake when there are 24 of them in your class, but I like to try!

Today, I had one student who did make some mistakes on his last two problems (see the picture of completed work before I helped him). He did not identify the problems needed to be flipped, he copied them again identically in the next space. What I wanted was for him to notice the order of the previous problems and follow the pattern to write a problem, then flip it. I did not catch it in the moment, which was disappointing, but I was able to pull him aside the next day and showed him his mistakes to help him understand.

# Commutative Property: First Grade Style

Lesson 8 of 10

## Objective: SWBAT use the commutative property of addition to solve addition problems.

#### Rev Them Up

*5 min*

We all know that our students are unique and learn in their own way. We need to teach lessons in multiple ways so that students have lots of opportunities to access material. The same goes for math lessons. I like to look at it as the beginning stages of creating an engineer. Engineers solve problems through different means, but we as teachers supply the different possible paths to pick from to solve a problem. Through perseverance with continued practice they will attempt different strategies and master the skill (MP1).

Strategies we have focused on are drawing pictures, counting with our fingers, counting on, and using objects.

I will have them do a quick review by asking: *Class, we have been learning several ways to solve an addition problem, and I would like to create a list on the chalkboard of all the ways to solve. What methods have we used? *

If any of our methods are left off, I will remind them of the ones we have used.

*expand content*

#### Whole Group Interaction

*15 min*

The commutative property teaches them numbers can be added in any order and still get to the same sum. I describe it to my kids that numbers can be flipped into a different order and they will help me discover that we get the same answer even if the numbers have changed position.

This strategy is very much a focus on the structure of algebraic thinking. I want them to notice the position of the numbers and how the numbers flipping doesn't change the sum.

I will bring my kids to a gathering spot in front of our chalk board and write the following problem on the board: 2+3=

I will ask them to help me solve it; then I will ask them, "What if I change it to 3+2=? ...", and I will write this on the board.

I expect some of my kids to already know the answer because some of them have their facts memorized, but others will not, so we will solve this problem also.

I will point at the answers for both and ask an open ended question: "What do you notice?"

My goal is to guide them towards understanding that the answer stayed the same, the addends stayed the same, and the addends just changed positions.

After this is achieved, I will write "commutative property" on the board and have them echo the word after me. Then I will share the definition of the commutative property. I will ask them to help me make a list of what strategies have we learned so far in adding and add commutative property to the list.

Watch as one student explained the commutative property.

#### Resources

*expand content*

#### Independent Practice

*10 min*

I wanted to provide a random method for students to create math problems for their practice. I designed the math sheet for students to add numbers they rolled using dice. They will roll a dice, write the number, then roll again and add that number to the first. When this is complete, the problem will be flipped, written down, and solved. My goal is for them to see the same answer is achieved even if the numbers are in a different position. If they know the answer to the first problem, it can help them reach the same answer for the second problem created from the same numbers. We will do the first two together, and then they are on their own.

Watch this video of getting them started.

This student is using the Commutative Property.

I realized the possibility could arise that the students would roll numbers that could equal 11 or 12 and many of my students are not ready for that at this time. While the CCSS expects a rigorous understanding of addition and subtraction with 2-digit products by the end of the year, I want to build up to that by starting with lower numbers. Once the students have a good grasp of properties with the lower numbers, we can move on to more challenging ones. I chose to not pass out dice for my students to roll; instead, I rolled, and we created the problems together. Then they had to use the strategy to solve their new problems.

You can differentiate the lesson by allowing higher students to roll a dice on their own and help your lower students with creating their own problems.

*expand content*

#### Closure

*5 min*

I called students back to the rug, and I put a simple problem on the board: 6+3=9.

I then asked students to turn to their partners and explain what answer you would get if you changed the problem to: 3+6=?

After a few moments of partner talk, I asked a few students to share their thinking with the group. We discussed that the sum would not change, and I asked students to tell me the name of the property that describes this idea in unison. They all called out, "commutative property!"

*expand content*

##### Similar Lessons

###### Recording Related Facts

*Favorites(9)*

*Resources(16)*

Environment: Urban

###### Crayon Box Combinations

*Favorites(6)*

*Resources(15)*

Environment: Urban

###### Assessment: Finding Combinations for 11

*Favorites(1)*

*Resources(21)*

Environment: Suburban

- UNIT 1: Ordering Numbers
- UNIT 2: Building Counting Skills
- UNIT 3: Addition Strategies
- UNIT 4: Understanding Subtraction
- UNIT 5: Word Problems
- UNIT 6: Understanding Shapes
- UNIT 7: Fractions
- UNIT 8: Measurement
- UNIT 9: Graphs, Tables, and Charts
- UNIT 10: Place Value
- UNIT 11: Subtraction Strategies
- UNIT 12: Understanding Time
- UNIT 13: Understanding Addition

- LESSON 1: Addition: Vocabulary Introduction
- LESSON 2: Making 6 & 7
- LESSON 3: Making 8
- LESSON 4: Representing Numbers on a Ten Frame
- LESSON 5: Addition Number Sentences
- LESSON 6: Is it true or false?
- LESSON 7: Addition Story Problems
- LESSON 8: Commutative Property: First Grade Style
- LESSON 9: Problem Solving: Using Objects
- LESSON 10: Understanding Addition:Unit Review, Test, and Test Strategy