Reflection: Self-Graded Rubrics The Lost Stanza of "Ulalume" - Section 3: Peer Review and Scoring


Sometimes a classroom feels like a token economy.  You give me work; I give you a grade.  I often feel that the students are really disconnected from the process of learning, because they are just collecting points.  And, let's be honest: English teachers have too much grading.  

While, I haven't found a satisfactory solution to the paper load (sorry!), I do think that students can be more invested in their work if they have a better understanding of how grades are derived.  I think that takes more than just showing them a rubric; they have to understand the skills that are being addressed and the approach that is being taken.

Today's activity left me feeling that the students really understood my expectations, and they seemed more comfortable trying to address the prompt (when they had an opportunity to rewrite.)  Though it is not at all realistic to expect to have time to undertake this task (which took about an hour) each time, I do think doing this a few times a year is really valuable.


  "Giving" and "getting" grades
  Self-Graded Rubrics: "Giving" and "getting" grades
Loading resource...

The Lost Stanza of "Ulalume"

Unit 6: Unlocking Mood and Other Elements of Horror
Lesson 13 of 18

Objective: SWBAT evaluate an omitted stanza of a poem for consistency; SWBAT participate in peer evaluation and scoring.

Big Idea: Reviewing the work of others can provide clarity about our own thinking and writing.

  Print Lesson
Add this lesson to your favorites
poe s wife inspiration for
Similar Lessons
Interpreting Symbolic Images Embedded in the Words of Kate Chopin, Langston Hughes and Dylan Thomas
9th Grade ELA » Poetry Analysis
Big Idea: Writers employ images that represent ideas to express their thoughts, and to leave us with a lasting memory of their ideas

Environment: Urban
Donna Fletcher
Writing and Evaluating Body Paragraphs For Document Based Question Essays
8th Grade ELA » Document Based Questions Essay
Big Idea: It's about the how and why, not just the what of using support: Using historical documents to supports claims.
Demarest, NJ
Environment: Suburban
Toby Murphy
Mystery Creatures Discovered... AAAHHH, It's a Spider!
8th Grade Science » Biodiversity and Spiders
Big Idea: Students begin to investigate the "alien" nature of spiders to begin to appreciate their beauty and importance.
Lake In The Hills, IL
Environment: Suburban
Lori Knasiak
Something went wrong. See details for more info
Nothing to upload