Modified Atwood Machine Lab

5 teachers like this lesson
Print Lesson

Objective

Students will be able to determine the relationship between net force, acceleration and mass and use it to create the Newton's Second Law equation.

Big Idea

A modified Atwood machine leads to equation creation.

Physics Families

10 minutes

The goal for this lesson is to have students use the Modified Atwood Machine to discover relationships between mass, force and acceleration. They develop that Newton's second law is an equation that related mass and acceleration inversely and acceleration and force directly from lab data which is a fulfillment of NGSS standard HS-PS2-1. Students use many skills like asking questions (SP1), determining independent and dependent variables, performing an experiment (SP3), and collecting and analyzing data (SP4). This lesson will lead to students sharing out data in a whiteboard session during the next class to develop both relationships further into a unified mathematical model of Newton's second law being a = F/m.

To start out class, I have students get in their Physics Families, since it is the beginning of the week. In today's activity, I want students to learn a little bit more about each other so I have them fill out a base group grid. A base group grid as a row for each group member and a column for each question the students are asked. I choose a few questions that are low risk and lead up to a little higher risk questions of goals for the class and the year. As you can see from the image below, the students really get to learn more about their group members and it is a nice way to get started for the week. 

Newton's Second Law Pre-Lab Discussion

20 minutes

After students return to their table groups from Physics families, I tell students that we are going to do another paradigm lab to start the unit. In each unit in the AMTA Modeling Curriculum, the unit starts out with a lab that helps to define a model for the unit that is written, graphical, diagrammatical and mathematical. Each unit starts out with one of these labs to provide students with the background they need to solve problems and work through situations during the units. 

I tell students that they need to make observations about the motion of a cart shown in the image below. I let go of the cart and allow it to move across the track. When the students have observed the motion, I ask them what observations they can make that are quantifiable or measurable. As a class, we come up with a list of measurable observations and the corresponding tools we would need to measure these observations. The most important variables that need to be included are mass, acceleration and force.

Once all of the measurable observations that the students come up with are listed, I start going through each observation and cross out any that appear unreasonable to students. I ask students if we have the appropriate tools to directly measure the variables they put on the board. By the end of the discussion we should be focused on three variables: mass, acceleration and force.

I then ask my students which should be the independent variable and which should be the dependent variable. This question leads them to thinking about how many experiments we need to complete. They should come up with acceleration as the dependent variable because it depends on the mass and force acting on the cart. 

When we have decided there will be two experiments, I ask them what he controls would be for each experiment and explain how they will do each part of the lab. It is very important for this lab that students know exactly what the controls are because they can effect the experiment a lot if they happen to change. For Experiment #1 (Acceleration vs. Force), students must make sure the mass is constant so they must start with the masses in the cart and transfer them to the mass hanger so the total mass of the system stays the same. For Experiment #2 (Acceleration vs. Mass), they need to keep the force constant so they only can add mass to the cart not the hanger.

 

Newton's Second Law Lab Data Collection

30 minutes

After students know what the two experiments are and how they to set them up, I ask students to move back to their lab tables to begin collecting data. Each group has 3-4 students so I ask that they select one person to be in charge of the moving the masses, one person to be in charge of making sure the cart does not come off the track at the end, and one person to be in control of the DataStudio computer program (mainly starting and stopping data collection). To make sure each group has someone in each role, I ask the masses changers to raise their hands and have someone with their hand raised explain what they will be doing. I do this for the other two roles as well to make sure that students know what they are responsible for. 

As students move to the back lab tables, they have a set-up already there for them. It includes a PASCO track with a cart on it. The cart has a string attached to it with a mass hanger on the other end. The mass set is on the table next to the set up. At one end of the track, I have placed feet on the track so students can increase the angle of the track to counteract friction. There is also a motion sensor to record the data. At the other end of the track, I have placed a pulley for the string to go on as the cart accelerates towards the end of the track. 


Students the work on collecting data for Experiment #1, I ask them to insert their data as they move through each trial into Plotly on one student's chromebook. I remind students that the acceleration will be the slope of the velocity vs. time graph so they need to determine that before they move onto the next trial. Then I remind them to take the mass on the mass hanger, convert to kg and then multiply by 10 (acceleration due to gravity) to get the force. Each group must collect data from 6 trials. 

Students then move onto Experiment #2 and collect the data using a similar process of finding the acceleration of the velocity vs. time graph and then writing down the mass in the cart (converted to kg) in their data table.

Newton's Second Law Lab Summary

10 minutes

When students have completed with data collection, I have them create two graphs in Plotly of their data. Similar to the first lab in this class, I have students complete a Lab Summary as a group prior to the whiteboard session that will be held in the day's class. Students work on a collaborative Google doc with their entire group. My suggestion to each group is for two people in the group to complete the lab summary information for the acceleration and mass data and two people in the group to complete the lab summary information for the acceleration and force data. This way they get both sets of data analyzed appropriately in the lab summary document before the end of class.

The lab summary allows students have all of the information submitted to me as a group before the they discuss their results as a class. The lab summary includes mathematical, graphical and written representations of their data. I do the lab summary so students have a chance to analyze their data prior to sharing through a whiteboard session. An example of the Lab Summary Student Work demonstrates how students are prepared for the Mega-Whiteboard session happening during the next lesson.