Organizing A Second Idea

Print Lesson


SWBAT independently produce clear and coherent writing by organizing their claim, reasons and evidence while thinking about counter argument.

Big Idea

Organizing is what you do before you do something, so that when you do it, it is not all mixed up. A. A. Milne

Lesson Opener

10 minutes

In my lesson openers I always have a "connect" in which I connect students' thinking about yesterday's lesson to today's lesson. I then have a "teach" in which I model for students the lesson of the day and also have them try it out. When I think about my modeling I use three categories; skill, strategy, and process. I model by stating the skill to the students, then giving them a strategy in which to use the skill, followed by the process to try out the strategy.

Connect: “Yesterday we brainstormed ideas for a 2nd essay, now we are going to organize all of that evidence and organize a counter argument.”

Teach: I will say, “In order to plan out our claim for this essay,  I am going to practice the skill of combining my thoughts under claim and strategy organzing my claim as well as the opposing claims. The process I will use is as follows:

1) Look through my evidence and claim.

2) Organize my claim and reasons in a logical manner.

3) Add one piece of evidence for each reason.

4) Add a second piece of evidence in order to plan for my counter argument.”

I will show students how I start drawing out my boxes and bullets. I put my claim in the “box” and my three reasons as the “bullet.”  I then show them how I think through the three main kinds of evidence; statistical, hypothetical and anecdotal and add a piece of evidence (my bracket) to my first bullet. I then show the students how I think to myself, “Hmmmm, what would be a claim my opposition would state,” then I add a second piece of evidence that would persuade my opposition. 

Active Engagement

5 minutes

Active Engagement: I will say, “Tell the person next to you your claim, one reason and one counter claim.”  I will check for understanding by listening to of each level of learner (at least 3 students-one who is at standard, one is approaching standard, and one who is above standard). I will have students share out their counter claim in order to help other students.

Closing of Active Engagement: Closing of Active Engagement: I will say, “Successful writers plan out the claim for this essay by combining their thoughts under one claim and the strategy of organizing their claim as well as the opposing claims. They organize their claim and reasons in a logical manner, then they organize their evidence by thinking about the counter claim.”

Independent Practice

25 minutes

Independent Practice:,”Start drawing your boxes and bullets and brackets, make sure your second piece of evidence will be used for a counter argument.”

Partner Work: Students will then be directed to turn and share boxes and bullets with their partners. I will direct students to do this after most students are done drafting their own organizational structure. to ensure they are starting their organizer successfully.

I will say, “Decide who will be partner A and who will be partner B. Partner A I want you to share how you organized your claim, reasons and evidence, concentrating on counter argument. Partner B, I want you to listen if Part A is showing that they understand how to organize with counter argument in mind. Then you will tell them if you heard a counter arugment. If not, give them feedback; tell them an idea of. Then you will switch.”

Independent Practice: I will say, “Now you are going to start writing out your evidence for one counter argument whle keeping your goal in mind from yesterday.”As they are working independently and quietly, (I like to play classical or smooth jazz for “writing” music (I just create a play list on Pandora Internet radio) I will have conferences with them about their writing by using the attached conference chart


5 minutes

I believe that the end of the lesson should be an assessment of the days’ learning; therefore it should be independent work. I always end class with an “exit ticket” in which students write down the response to a question.

Closing: “What is an example of your claim, one reason, and two pieces of evidence (one that will address your counter claim).”