## Reflection: High Quality Task Muddying the Waters: Formative Assessment Lesson - Section 3: Small Group Collaboration and Share Out

Student Work A:  This is a case of a student clearly catching on to the flow of a discussion, without thinking for themselves.  In the midst of a group or whole class discussion, I commonly tell my students not to "be puppets" and think for themselves.  This student clearly understood the goal of the task without internalizing any reasons for her claims.  Although she understood the overall idea, her reasoning was just as flawed as the statistics she was seeking to refute.

Student Work B:  This is an exemplary response from a student who conveyed her ideas in writing very well.  I really appreciated how she worded the second paragraph as "Not necessarily..."  When teaching flaws in statistical analysis, students often jump the gun and try to refute everything that is not statistically sound thinking.  It is important to recognize that even though the data collected is not sufficient enough to make a claim, it doesn't mean that the claim itself might not be true... It just can't be concluded from the data that was gathered.  I shared this "Not necessarily" wording with the whole class on the following day.  Excellent work!

# Muddying the Waters: Formative Assessment Lesson

Unit 4: Statistics: Something for Everyone
Lesson 21 of 21

## Big Idea: DANGER! Statistics get misapplied in many real world applications!

Print Lesson
2 teachers like this lesson
Standards:
Subject(s):
Math, Algebra II, master teacher project
45 minutes

### Jarod Hammel

##### Similar Lessons

###### Describing Data - Day 1 of 2
Algebra I » Data and Statistics
Big Idea: How would you describe these numbers without just writing a list? Students work together to describe data both in words and in visual representations.
Favorites(14)
Resources(12)
Boston, MA
Environment: Urban

###### The Game of Greed
12th Grade Math » Statistics: Data in One Variable
Big Idea: Sticky notes make this data set a manipulative that can be rearranged as student understandings of statistical representations evolve.
Favorites(44)
Resources(17)
Worcester, MA
Environment: Urban

###### Our City Statistics Project and Assessment
Algebra I » Our City Statistics: Who We Are and Where We are Going
Big Idea: Students demonstrate interpersonal and data literacy skills as use statistics to learn about their community.
Favorites(9)
Resources(17)
Salem, MA
Environment: Urban