Reflection: Developing a Conceptual Understanding Mystery Bags Game  Section 1: Opening
I really like how this activity surfaces the idea for students that balance has to be maintained in an equation. Too often I see students manipulating equations or "doing the same thing to each side" without really understanding why. I like the build up here to solving equations by maintaining equality. I think it is a powerful image that can really stick with students and help their conceptual understanding of what an equation is.
Mystery Bags Game
Lesson 9 of 14
Objective: SWBAT solve simple equations and justify their solution method.
Opening
In this lesson, students use the concept a pan balance model to understand equivalency and solve linear equations. IMP uses the context of a "mystery bags" that are filled with gold and placed on the pan balance. All mystery bags weigh the same amount when they are place don the scale. Known weights are also placed on the scale and students must use what they know about keeping the balance level in order to figure out how many ounces of gold are in each bag. Students may be familiar with a similar model and may already be able to solve simple equations. The focus here is both on the "why" of solving equations and getting students to justify their and answers by constructing a viable solution.
The task in this activity is taken from IMP's Year 1 Textbook (2009), pages 252253.
You can begin class with a visual like the one in the Resources section for students to figure out. This is a fairly easy problem to figure out, so place an emphasis here on how students know the weight of each bag. Ask them to prove it to you. Then let them get to work individually on the remaining problems.
Resources (1)
Resources (1)
Resources
Investigation
There is only 20 minutes allocated in this section for students to work. You want to leave time in this class not only for discussion, but also for students to go back to the problems and write algebraic equations. Therefore, pay close attention to time during this lesson!
As students work, keep an eye out for the following issues:
 Depending on the level of your students, you may want to provide some blank pan balance sheets for them to work with. Other students may be comfortable finding their own way to draw the situation.
 In Question 4, there are mystery bags on both sides of the balance. Students may need prompting to remove the bags. Focus on keeping the balance level here. Ask students if they take one bag off of one side, what will happen to the other side?
 In Question 5, there is weight and mystery bags to take off of both sides.
 Questions 6 & 7 have a trick. Try not to give too much guidance to students here, but look for volunteers who might be able to share out some of their thinking in the Discussion portion of the lesson.
Discussion + Group Work
Have students report out their answers on Questions 2 through 7. Pay special attention to Questions 6 & 7. In Question 6, there are 6 bags and 13 ounces on one side and 6 bags and 14 ounces on the other side. This is impossible! Elicit ideas from students about what could be happening  perhaps the scale is unbalanced or the bags of gold are not all the same. In Question 7, the bags of gold could come out to any weight because the number of bags and the amount of weight on each side is the same.
Next, ask students if they could describe, in words, the procedure that they used to to find out how much gold is in a mystery bag no matter what the scale looks like. Keep track of what they say on a SmartBoard or white board (Mystery Bags_video narrative).
Now, return to the original scale from the start of class and ask students how they could represent this scale using algebra. If students are stumped, you might suggest using a letter (like B) to represent a mystery bag. Next, ask students to return to Questions 2 through 7 in small groups and write an equation for each one.
Resources (1)
Resources (1)
Closing + Homework
Bring the class back together and ask students to share out equations. You might start with one like Question 5, where there are different amounts of bags and weights on each side. Ask students to match up the steps they wrote earlier for figuring out how much each bag weighed with their algebraic equations. You might write 11B + 65 = 4B + 100 on the board next to their steps and ask them how they can represent the steps algebraically. You might say, "Earlier you said you took the same amount of mystery bags off of each side of the scale. How can you show that using algebra and this equation? How can you write about removing bags from each side? How many did you take away?" With students participating, show the rest of the steps.
Try to have students raise the idea or question about what order to work in. You might demonstrate that it does not matter if the weight or the mystery bags are removed first. This is a good opportunity to write the same equation side by side and show the steps in a different order.
Remember, that an important piece of this standard is students being able to justify their steps and create a viable argument. To that end, take each step slowly and make sure students are able to explain why they doing it.
Students will continue this work in tonight's homework. More Mystery Bags is an appropriate follow up assignment on page 254 of the IMP Year 1 textbook (2009). At the end of class you can introduce the assignment to students and if there is time, let them get started on the work. Part of the assignment asks students to create their own equations and describe the pan balance set up. Make sure they do this part of the assignment as you will use it at the start of the next lesson as an Opening activity.

This material is adapted from the IMP Teacher’s Guide, © 2010 Interactive Mathematics Program. Some rights reserved.
Similar Lessons
NonLinear Systems of Equations
Environment: Urban
Solving Equations by Constructing Arguments (Day 1 of 2)
Environment: Urban
Unit Assessment: Linear Equations in 1 Variable
Environment: Urban
 UNIT 1: Introduction to Algebra: Focus on Problem Solving
 UNIT 2: Multiple Representations: Situations, Tables, Graphs, and Equations
 UNIT 3: Systems of Equations and Inequalities
 UNIT 4: Quadratics!
 UNIT 5: Data and Statistics
 UNIT 6: Arithmetic & Geometric Sequences
 UNIT 7: Functions
 LESSON 1: First Day of Class  The Marshmallow Challenge
 LESSON 2: How Does This Math Class Work? Creating a Positive Classroom Climate
 LESSON 3: Generating Student Discourse
 LESSON 4: What Makes Something a Pattern?
 LESSON 5: The Broken Eggs
 LESSON 6: Introduction to Functions
 LESSON 7: Tables, Words, and Equations
 LESSON 8: A Communication Challenge
 LESSON 9: Mystery Bags Game
 LESSON 10: Writing About Math in the Cafeteria
 LESSON 11: PostIt Note Equations
 LESSON 12: Solving for x
 LESSON 13: Inequalities: True or False?
 LESSON 14: The Great Inequality Debate