Reflection: Adjustments to Practice Magic Witch Hats - Section 4: Magic Witch Hats


I have to find a different way of facilitating this lesson. I think it was particularly confusing for my students because we had just been working on equivalent expressions. They had been focused on understanding why subtracting was equivalent to 'adding the opposite'. When students ended up with -3 + (-5) next to -3 + (+5) they got confused because they weren't equivalent.

My intention was to cement the idea that addition problems don't need to change and that changing subtraction makes it 'friendlier'. If I had been explicit about my intentions with students or if I had asked them questions like:


  • "Why did I make subtraction the bad witch?" (because it is a harder problem)
  • "In what ways are the good and bad witches the same/different?" (starts with the same number, opposite operation, different answers - not equivalent)
  • "Why do I say every bad witch has a good side?" (because the problem can be exchanged for a 'friendlier' one)
  • "After exchanging the subtraction for addition, how do the two witches compare?" (they are still the opposite)
  • "What two expressions are equivalent?" (the two expressions for the bad witch)
  • "Why did we not have to exchange the good witch's expression?" and "what would it look like if we did?" and "why is that not helpful?"


The second and fourth questions may highlight that the two expressions are still opposite:

  • subtracting negative five is the opposite of adding negative five
  • adding negative five is still the opposite of adding positive five

  This might be too confusing
  Adjustments to Practice: This might be too confusing
Loading resource...

Magic Witch Hats

Unit 4: Operations with Integers
Lesson 17 of 24

Objective: SWBAT add the opposite instead of subtracting integers.

Big Idea: Students will understand that subtracting is like "canceling out".

  Print Lesson
1 teacher likes this lesson
Math, Number Sense and Operations, Operations and Expressions, subtracting integers, Additive inverse, halloween, student ownership
  54 minutes
Similar Lessons
How Addition and Subtraction are Related (Part 2 of 3)
7th Grade Math » Rational Number Operations
Big Idea: Students will use counters to prove that a difference can be written as a sum.
New Orleans, LA
Environment: Urban
Grant Harris
Subtracting Integers - How does subtraction relate to addition?
7th Grade Math » Operations with Rational Numbers
Big Idea: Subtraction does not have to be any harder than addition – students will turn all subtraction problems into addition problems and use the rules they have already mastered!
Elon, NC
Environment: Suburban
Heather Stephan
Relative Error Spiral Lesson
8th Grade Math » Statistical Spirals
Big Idea: We all make mistakes, but it is important to quantify the level of the mistake relative to the situation you are working with. This is the fundamental idea of relative error.
New York, NY
Environment: Urban
Shaun Errichiello
Something went wrong. See details for more info
Nothing to upload