##
* *Reflection: Discourse and Questioning
The Weight of the Matter - Section 4: Closing and Sharing

If your students are like many of mine, they are used to, or expect, answers quickly and certainly by the end of a lesson! Every now and then, I like to leave them without everything neatly wrapped up in a "completed" picture.

In this lesson, the task was fairly simple and I am setting the students up to gather precise data and then to explore its meaning. By leaving the class with an unanswered question, I am actually giving them time to let the information from the session sink in. They are given time to explore their thinking without feeling the need to come up with the answer quickly.

This accomplishes at least two things. It maintains the motivation of lesson and it forces the students to begin to be okay with answers that come a little later. That patience and ability to consider strategies or possible solutions over time will serve them well all of their learning lives.

*A Question Left Unanswered*

*Discourse and Questioning: A Question Left Unanswered*

# The Weight of the Matter

Lesson 4 of 6

## Objective: Students will be able to measure objects using non-standard units. They will then explore reasons to use standard units.

## Big Idea: Students have not had many chances in life to measure weight, nor to explore the units of measure. As scientists, it is important to express findings in a standard way. This lesson helps students determine the why of that concept.

*50 minutes*

#### Question

*5 min*

Today, we will explore the idea of mass. I will ask the students, **"What do scientists do in order to measure the mass of matter?"**

I will have students turn and talk about this question in order to create a common interest in today's exploration. As the partners discuss, I will listen in and try to find a partnership that will discuss the idea of a scale, or a tool to find weight.

The idea of finding the weight of an object is part of teaching children that investigating every property is important in the description of that object. The 5 senses aren't enough often times.

*expand content*

#### Mini Lesson

*10 min*

To begin the lesson, I will explain to the students that there are tools scientists use in order to measure the weight of objects. I will ask them to recall how they know how much they weigh and if there are ever times they witness their parents weighing objects. (Most student are able to identify a time their parents weighed produce or other objects at the grocery store.)

I will show and model a pan balance to the students. I will discuss with them how to make each side "balance", or become equal in weight. I will tell the students that we are going to use this balance to find the weight of 3 objects: a metal disc, a wood square, and a plastic chip.

I will also tell them that there are paperclips on their tray, which will be the units of weight. So, we will be trying to find how many paperclips each objects weighs.

**What I don't tell them is that each tray has different sized clips than the other trays. **This will set us up for a conversation on the importance of standard units and standard practices in science.

*expand content*

#### Active Engagement

*25 min*

As teams measure the weight of objects, I will circulate and check for precision and ask probing questions regarding what they think about the outcomes they are getting during the task.

Measuring weight is a very precise procedure and students often want to rush through it. As I spoke with this group, and several others, I had to remind them that they needed to let the balance naturally stop moving before they could decide on whether or not to put in paperclips, take some out, or if it was balanced.

This next group was weighing the same object, the metal disc, and found a different result. I explained to them that another group got a different number of paperclips and they immediately began to question why. I was so pleased to hear them talk about variables, rather than just thinking the other team did it wrong, or that they, themselves, made a mistake.

*expand content*

#### Closing and Sharing

*10 min*

To close the lesson, I will leave the students with a lingering question, which we will visit in the next lesson.

I will call all of the student teams to the community area and have them report out their measurements of the three objects. I will list these numbers on the board. Obviously, they will not be the same. Some of them will be close, but others will be very far apart, due to the different sized clips. At this point, the students are still not aware they were using different sized clips. Before asking my question, I will ask the students if they notice anything about the reported weights of each object.

Hopefully, the students will report that the numbers are different, some are close together, some are far apart, and some are exactly the same.

My question will be, "What could cause these numbers to be so different?" I will then instruct the teams to turn into small discussion groups and talk about this.

Following a few minutes, I will ask the class to share their thoughts as a whole and then tell them that tomorrow I will give them another option to think about.

*expand content*

*Thank you for your feedback. I am so pleased you found the lesson useful. I wonder what the factor would be...sometimes it is an on day and sometimes not! | 20 days ago | Reply*

This lesson was great; getting the students doing hands-on activities activates their learning more than anything else. My students were a little confused as to why the other groups' measurements were inconsistent, so there was a bit more teacher involvement than in your class. (I teach in an International School in a foreign country - could be a factor).

Thank you

| one month ago | Reply##### Similar Lessons

###### I Can Measure Mass, Not Weight, With A Triple Beam Balance!

*Favorites(8)*

*Resources(12)*

Environment: Suburban

###### Natural Resources

*Favorites(2)*

*Resources(14)*

Environment: Suburban

###### Recognizing Relationships: Compare and Contrast

*Favorites(32)*

*Resources(17)*

Environment: Rural

- UNIT 1: Finding the Scientist Within
- UNIT 2: Structures of Life: Seeds
- UNIT 3: Structures of Life: Crayfish
- UNIT 4: Ecosystems and Biological Evolution
- UNIT 5: Energy
- UNIT 6: Light Energy
- UNIT 7: Matter
- UNIT 8: Magnets
- UNIT 9: Electricity
- UNIT 10: Engineering and Design: Saving the Little Brown Bat
- UNIT 11: End of Year Activities