## Reflection: Developing a Conceptual Understanding Definitely, Maybe - Section 1: Definitely, Maybe

When facilitating this discussion, I made the decision to create a rule that students could NOT ask questions that simply had yes or no answers.  For example, I did not allow students to pose questions like, “is the picture showing a polar bear?”, “did two people exchange vows?”, or “is this a rectangle?”  What this rule did was require students to think harder about the characteristics that would guarantee the polar bear was indeed a polar bear, for example, by asking “where does this creature live?” or “what might this creature eat?”  As a result, students were able to get a clearer idea of the kinds of assumptions they can and cannot make based on what is given to them.

Because I barred questions with yes or no answers, something surprising happened when students got to the picture that showed a "square": some students decided to use rulers and protractors to measure.  Some students even folded the rectangle along one of its diagonals to show that the diagonal was not a line of symmetry, therefore the rectangle could not be a square as well.   This was an unexpected surprise, and I am glad that it came up because it continues to reinforce the transformational lens I want my students to use throughout their year in geometry.

Important Decisions to Make When Facilitating the Whole Class Discussion
Developing a Conceptual Understanding: Important Decisions to Make When Facilitating the Whole Class Discussion

# Definitely, Maybe

Unit 2: Introducing Geometry
Lesson 1 of 8

## Big Idea: Students question assumptions they make, engage in deductive reasoning and defend their reasoning by examining real-life photographs and a geometric figure.

Print Lesson
3 teachers like this lesson
Standards:
Subject(s):
Math, Geometry, deductive reasoning, definition, basic properties
65 minutes

### Jessica Uy

##### Similar Lessons

###### Angles and Rotations
12th Grade Math » Rotations and Cyclical Functions
Big Idea: While learning basic angle terminology students are engaged through multiple clicker questions in this introductory lesson to circular functions.
Favorites(8)
Resources(17)
Phoenix, AZ
Environment: Urban

###### Reviewing Geometric Models
Geometry » Models and Constructions
Big Idea: We have applied the properties of these objects in modeling situations. Now, what have we learned by "doing geometry"?
Favorites(7)
Resources(27)
Ault, CO
Environment: Rural

###### Circles are Everywhere
Geometry » Circles
Big Idea: This lesson asks students to create real circles and then review key vocabulary connected with circles like diameter, radius, center, secant, tangent and center.
Favorites(31)
Resources(24)
Saratoga Springs, NY
Environment: Suburban