Reflection: Real World Applications Socratic Seminar: Using conversation to show how to closely read a text - Section 4: Socratic Seminar Reflection


During today's Socratic Seminar, two students really disagreed about one of the points from the article.  Student A was a firm believer that students are responsible for their own education and should have full responsibility for that education despite who the teacher is.  Student B disagreed and explained that teachers have to have some, if not most of, the blame for a student's failing grade.  Throughout the Seminar, these two students brought up many points and pieces of evidence to support his/her opinion.  During the reflection, Student A realized that Student B had some valid points.  She wrote:

I realized today that not everyone has had the same educational experience I have.  He (Student B) had a horrible experience in 8th grade Science that has changed him as a student.  I didn't understand what points he was trying to make, but while I write this reflection, I understand we don't have the same background and that makes our perspectives different.  

What a great teacher moment! 

  Agreeing to disagree is a life skill
  Real World Applications: Agreeing to disagree is a life skill
Loading resource...

Socratic Seminar: Using conversation to show how to closely read a text

Unit 16: Creative Test Prep and Review
Lesson 1 of 6

Objective: SWBAT qualify or justify their own views about a subject by engaging in a Socratic Seminar over a common text.

Big Idea: Can students deepen their thinking and reading by having quality conversations with each other?

  Print Lesson
4 teachers like this lesson
socraticcircle 1
Similar Lessons
Formulating and Defending Opinions: Determining Grammy's Best and Worst Dressed
9th Grade ELA » Poetry Analysis
Big Idea: To support your point of view, you must have reasons and evidence (facts, details and information); to understand another person's point of view, you must be able to identify the reasons and evidence he/she provides.

Environment: Urban
Donna Fletcher
Speed Date Writing Workshop: Revising and Editing with Peers
9th Grade ELA » Actions and Reactions: Comparison Contrast Essay
Big Idea: Students go on speed dates with their peers' essays by focusing on specific revisions and edits
Bel Air, MD
Environment: Suburban
Paula Stanton
Finding Evidence to support analysis of the short story "Sucker"
9th Grade ELA » Short Fiction: Back to Basics
Big Idea: Reading and analyzing "Sucker," a story of broken friendships.
Springfield, MA
Environment: Urban
SiriNam Khalsa
Something went wrong. See details for more info
Nothing to upload