RL.2.9

Compare and contrast two or more versions of the same story (e.g., Cinderella stories) by different authors or from different cultures.

 
24 Lesson(s)
   

Cinder-Elly: Day 1 of Cinderella Unit

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Fractured Fairly Tales
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Fractured Fairly Tales
Dr. Miranti Murphy
Hollywood, FL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

As an introduction to different perspectives on the same story, students will analyze text of a different version of a familiar story.

 
Favorites (28)
 
Resources (26)
 
Reflections (2)
cinderelly
   

Details, Details, Details - Finding the Theme and Details in 3 Versions of a Story

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Connecting with Key Details and Theme
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Connecting with Key Details and Theme
Andrea Praught
Oswego, IL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

The fables differ in their plot and theme – let’s look at the versions and make connections.

 
Favorites (32)
 
Resources (26)
 
Reflections (1)
details details books
   

Connecting To The Theme with Elmer!

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Connecting with Key Details and Theme
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Connecting with Key Details and Theme
Andrea Praught
Oswego, IL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

What's the theme of the story and why is it important to me?

 
Favorites (52)
 
Resources (25)
 
Reflections (1)
connecting the theme lesson image
   

Two Versions of A Fable - Same Summary

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Summarizing: Use Main Idea and Supporting Details
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Summarizing: Use Main Idea and Supporting Details
Andrea Praught
Oswego, IL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

Two versions of a fable-summarize and see if they’re the same!

 
Favorites (15)
 
Resources (31)
 
Reflections (1)
lesson image
   

Yeh-Shen, the Chinese Cinderella: Day 2 of Cinderella Unit

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Fractured Fairly Tales
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Fractured Fairly Tales
Dr. Miranti Murphy
Hollywood, FL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

Puppetry can be used to dramatize a different version of the same fictional story while foreshadowing similar key details.

 
Favorites (6)
 
Resources (18)
 
Reflections (1)
yeg shen cinderella
   

Cindy Ellen: Day 4 of Cinderella Unit

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Fractured Fairly Tales
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Fractured Fairly Tales
Dr. Miranti Murphy
Hollywood, FL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

By analyzing this Wild Western version of Cinderella, students will gain new perspectives of how a story with a similar central theme can have different points of view.

 
Favorites (9)
 
Resources (17)
 
Reflections (1)
cinderella cindy ellen wild west
   

The Golden Sandal: Day 3 of Cinderella Unit

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Fractured Fairly Tales
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Fractured Fairly Tales
Dr. Miranti Murphy
Hollywood, FL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

Comparing the familiar with an unfamiliar version gives students opportunity to analyze multiple perspectives.

 
Favorites (3)
 
Resources (18)
 
Reflections (1)
cinderella mid east golden sandal
   

Wow - Same story, but different problems and solutions!

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Introduction to 2nd grade - Literature has Story Elements
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Introduction to 2nd grade - Literature has Story Elements
Andrea Praught
Oswego, IL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

Fables from other countries - compare/contrast and look at the problem and solution!

 
Favorites (14)
 
Resources (25)
 
Reflections (1)
jack the beanstalk image
   

The Korean Cinderella: Day 5 of Cinderella Unit

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Fractured Fairly Tales
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Fractured Fairly Tales
Dr. Miranti Murphy
Hollywood, FL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

As an important literary technique,differences in perspective and point of view are exemplified in stories with the same central theme, such as this Korean version of CInderella

 
Favorites (9)
 
Resources (13)
 
Reflections (1)
cinderella korean
   

Abuelo and the Three Bears Day 1 of 2

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Folktales
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Folktales
Maricela Rodriguez
Los Angeles, CA
Environment: Urban
 
Big Idea:

Every culture has it's unique way of telling folktales. Will Trencitas (Goldilocks) eat all the frijoles (beans) while the three bears take their walk?

 
Favorites (3)
 
Resources (31)
 
Reflections (1)
i know i know
   
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Cinderella Unit
Maricela Rodriguez
Los Angeles, CA
Environment: Urban
 
Big Idea:

Glass slippers, pumpkin carriages, fairy godmothers! I can't believe how many Cinderella stories there are!

 
Favorites (4)
 
Resources (28)
 
Reflections (1)
what story will you select
   

Connect To the World and Don't use 'Slug'gish Words

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Connecting with Key Details and Theme
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Connecting with Key Details and Theme
Andrea Praught
Oswego, IL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

Use voice to show a character's point of view!

 
Favorites (5)
 
Resources (26)
 
Reflections (1)
slug image
   
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Cinderella Unit
Maricela Rodriguez
Los Angeles, CA
Environment: Urban
 
Big Idea:

Comparing and contrasting different versions of stories helps students gain a deep level of comprehension of the stories.

Standards:
 
Favorites (9)
 
Resources (24)
 
Reflections (2)
mettask
   

Ouch! There's a Pea Under the Mattress! (Lesson 1 of 3)

2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Inference-What Do You Already Know and How Does the Text Help You?
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Inference-What Do You Already Know and How Does the Text Help You?
Andrea Praught
Oswego, IL
Environment: Suburban
 
Big Idea:

Three stories! Compare, Constrast and Infer the Ideas!

 
Favorites (3)
 
Resources (32)
 
Reflections (1)
lesson image
   
2nd Grade ELA » Unit: Cinderella Unit
Maricela Rodriguez
Los Angeles, CA
Environment: Urban
 
Big Idea:

Balls to attend! Clocks striking 12! What's the same? What's different?

 
Favorites (2)
 
Resources (19)
 
Reflections (1)
sharingcomparing and contrasting
Common Core ELA
 
Something went wrong. See details for more info
Nothing to upload
details
close