Peer to Peer Scoring: Peer to Peer Scoring Annotations Native Son.pdf

 
 
 
Compiled Responses to Peer Annotation Scoring for Native Son Book 1 - Form Responses 1.pdf
Student Work Sample
 
 
This is the spreadsheet generated by the Google Form Warm-Up. The Warm-Up asked students to view and then score selected peers' annotations.
  • Peer to Peer Scoring Annotations Native Son.pdf
  • Peer to Peer Scoring Annotations Native Son.pdf
  • Peer to Peer Scoring Annotations Native Son.pdf
  • Peer to Peer Scoring Annotations Native Son.pdf
  • Peer to Peer Scoring Annotations Native Son.pdf
Student Work Sample
 
 
This is the spreadsheet generated by the Google Form Warm-Up. The Warm-Up asked students to view and then score selected peers' annotations.
 
Feedback Systems

Peer to Peer Scoring

Peer to Peer Scoring is a feedback strategy I use regularly to ensure that my students become comfortable with and skillful at giving and receiving feedback about their academic work. In most cases, I develop rubrics to assess a particular skill and I ask the students to use the rubrics to score their peers' work on a given assignment. This strategy creates a common understanding of high-quality academic performance and the standards we use to assess that quality. Peer to Peer Scoring affords my students multiple opportunities to explain clearly their reasons for coming to a particular assessment of their peers' work, thereby helping each student to internalize what rigorous intellectual work consists of. Peer to Peer Scoring is also an effective scaffolding strategy to prepare my students for their Senior Research Projects, a rigorous graduation requirement at our school that culminates in seniors getting feedback from community members.

Strategy Resources (2)
Students In Action
 
 
 
Student Work Sample
 
 
This is the spreadsheet generated by the Google Form Warm-Up. The Warm-Up asked students to view and then score selected peers' annotations.
 
Students In Action
 
 
Student Work Sample
 
 
This is the spreadsheet generated by the Google Form Warm-Up. The Warm-Up asked students to view and then score selected peers' annotations.
Johanna Paraiso
Fremont High School Oakland
Oakland, CA


 

About this strategy

Prep Time:
Moderate
Subject:
English / Language Arts
Grade:
Twelfth grade
Similar Strategies
Independent Student Learning
Annotation Logs

Annotation Logs in my class can be on paper or online, usually depending on what modality the student prefers, as well as what their access is to technology at home. Annotation Logs are a routine through which my students explore the unit text by analyzing quotes, asking questions, and making clarifications. Whether online or on paper, it is my routine to respond to their annotations. Because each student writes so many annotations throughout a unit, I have many opportunities to dip into their thinking at multiple points along the way. Annotation Logs are fundamental building blocks to some of my other classroom practices including Socratic Seminars, TIED analysis paragraphs, and essay writing. For each annotation in the log, my students must include their focus for the annotation, the quote itself, the page or line number, and the analysis. The focus of the annotation could be a literary device, a theme connection or an approach through one of the literary theory lenses we have studied. Citing the quote and where it is found makes for easy reference later on. The analysis is 3-4 sentences that shows how the quote addresses the initial focus they indicated. It is in this last part that I address any feedback by asking questions and clarifying any plot confusion.

 
Instructional Openings
Conversational Warm-Up

Generating student talk in the classroom is a focal point for my teaching, and it is important that those conversations happen in both high-stakes and low-stakes settings. A Warm-Up is the forum for a low-stakes conversation that can generate a high return. For example, the journey for a student to become an excellent oral presenter can be an uncomfortable one. Opening class with a conversation where students can talk with each other in anticipation of these growing pains does perpetuate a sense of camaraderie and support, although my students have referred to it as a feeling of "shared doom". Additionally, a teacher can have an influence on the energy of the class depending on what prompts are crafted for the Conversational Warm-Up.


 
Learning Apps
Johanna's Digital Content and Tech Tools

There are an infinite number of digital content providers and tech tools and education programs a blended teacher can choose to use in her classroom. Check out how and why Johanna uses specific digital content and ed tech tools!


 
 
Something went wrong. See details for more info
Nothing to upload
details
close